A properly witnessed will is simply more ironclad. When drafting a will, its important to understand several requirements, including who can serve as a witness. Instagram. What are the Duties of an Executor of a Will? One-Time Checkup with a Financial Advisor, enlisting the services of afinancial advisor, 7 Mistakes You'll Make When Hiring a Financial Advisor, Take This Free Quiz to Get Matched With Qualified Financial Advisors, Compare Up to 3 Financial Advisors Near You. Direct Cremation, Beyond Blog The Last Word For a similar reason, its also better if you dont choose someone who usually lives abroad pick someone who can easily be found if theyre needed to vouch for your will. If you are not sure what rule to follow, an attorney in your state will know what rule is required in your state. You may also run into challenges if youre asking someone who has a mental impairment or a visual impairment to witness your will. You do, however, need two witnesses to sign your Will in front of you and each other. The process for witnessing the signatures on a will is fairly simple. while this is not a court document they may well be happy to witness it and (should) know that it isn't a scam and does n't impose any liability on them. The role of a witness is to confirm that the will has been signed by the person making it. Be Sure Your End of Life Wishes Are Carried Out, If you're looking for more resources on writing your will, read our guides on the. If you have already begun this process, why not take the extra step to prevent any challenges down the road? The Tennessee Court of Appeals disagreed. Your bank will likely notarize anything but a Will or a Trust free of charge. Notarizing and witnessing documents properly can make all the difference, whether the document is filed with a county clerk or submitted to a court. : to have the power or skill to (do something) This is the minimum number of witnesses required by state will-making laws. January 18, 2023, 2:56 AM. The process of getting a Will witnessed and notarized is not as difficult as it may sound. SmartAsset does not review the ongoing performance of any Adviser, participate in the management of any users account by an Adviser or provide advice regarding specific investments. Perhaps you can go to a bank and have a notary and another bank employee witness the document. Thats where Cleon H. Cookes daughter took Mr. Cooke to sign a new will in 1995. subject to our Terms of Use. 0 found this answer helpful | 0 lawyers agree Helpful Unhelpful 0 comments Theodore Lyons Araujo View Profile 25 reviews Avvo Rating: 10 Chapter 7 Bankruptcy Attorney in Monday-Friday: Opens: 8 am, Closes 5 pm Having said that, it is obviously better if they are fully independent, particularly if there is any risk of a challenge on the basis of something like undue influence, where best practice would be that the customer takes independent advice before signing. i would think they will. Who is a competent witness? Lets say you have significant assets or you need to make arrangements for the care of minor children. The exact requirements on where to get a Will witnessed and notarized will vary slightly depending on where you live. Your witnesses should be legal adults (18 in most states) and of sound mind. Probate Service Most states require that witnesses be "disinterested"in other words, that they not stand to inherit under the terms of the will. drum. The requirements for witnessing a will vary from state to state but generally, all states require witnesses to satisfy three basic rules for the will to be valid: Have the correct number of witnesses. Most lawyers recommend not having They may be dead. Witness a Will: Frequently Asked Questions. No, never. Just as a testator must be of sound mind when they sign their will, a witness must be of sound mind to serve as a valid witness. Ms. Pitt went out to the car with Mr. Cookes daughter, and watched him sign his will; she then took the document inside the bank and got two other bank employees to sign as witnesses, and then she notarized the document. We don't as a general policy investigate the solvency of companies mentioned (how likely they are to go bust), but there is a risk any company can struggle and it's rarely made public until it's too late (see the. It is a serial half-duplex and asynchronous type of communication protocol. Expert. In some states, they might have to appear before the court or, at least, provide an affidavit if the will is not made self-proving. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Secure your well-being and that of those you love. The requirement for a witness to be "credible" meant no more than "competent", and did not require the witness to be "independent". Why do you have to use family at all? So for example, if youre drafting a will that leaves assets to your spouse, children, siblings or parents, none of them would be able to witness the wills signing since they all have an interest in the wills terms. Notarized wills. But when Mr. Cooke died, his widow contested the will. I need to know what he My ex-husband died intestate with a sizeable 401K and no named beneficiary (more on RE: Total of 13 siblingsthe 6 siblings own 1/6 undivided interest in the land as More Probate, Trusts, Wills & Estates questions and answers in Georgia. The scammer explains that they will send you $8000, and then you send them $4000. Have the correct number of witnesses. Although some states have required three witnesses to validate a will, currently all states require only two witnesses to witness the testators signature on the will. The testator is the person making the will. Witness the signatures appropriately. Though both have the same word in it, they come into play at different points in time. You can also use a reputable self-help service such as Nolo's Quicken WillMaker to make your own will. But married couples can witness a will together, as long as they dont have an interest in it. The people who sign your will cant benefit from its contents in any way. This link will open in a new window. Is there a difference in the bank's liability? Anyone who might lack the mental capacity to understand what it is they are signing Remember! If a beneficiary witnesses your will, the will is still valid, but they will automatically lose their inheritance they wont receive the gift you are leaving them. There are a few states that may allow a will to be notarized instead of being signed by two witnesses. Some states now provide for notarized wills, which means that a notary public may notarize the testators signature without the need for other witnesses. There is no notary. If a beneficiary (or the spouse of a beneficiary) does sign a will, the will remains valid, but the beneficiary wont be able to claim the gifts left to them. A power of attorney which might be used for a reverse mortgage or other home financing must be signed in the office of a lawyer, at a bank or in the office of a title insurance company. New York is another state that allows you to include a self-proving affidavit, which will need to be notarized. In some states, the witnesses dont have to be in the same room when they sign the will. In others, they dont even have to watch the will-maker sign, as long as the person later tells the witnesses that he or she signed the document. Or they may be allowed to watch the will-maker sign the will, and sign it later themselves. If you're signing the will at an attorney's office, the attorney will probably bring in witnessesemployees of the law firm or someone who works next door, for example. Relatives who are not part of your will, such as cousins, aunts, uncles, etc. a sealed container for food, beverages, etc., as of aluminum, sheet iron coated with tin, or other metal: a can of soup. Not everyone can be a witness to a will. Mr. Cooke waited in the car while his daughter went inside and talked to notary Beverly Pitt, a Customer Service Representative at the Bank. Two or more nodes are required on the CAN network to communicate. Notaries are often available at real estate offices, postal services, or banks. If all the people who witnessed the signing of a will are in agreement about your intent and mental state when you made it, then it becomes harder for someone else to dispute its legality. Most states will allow an interested witness to serve as a witness and receive their designated interest under the will provided there are two other disinterested witnesses available to witness the testator sign the will. What I did for my own will and what I recommend to clients is to go the UPS store or some other place that offers notary services and wait till 2 customers come in. Without the required number of witnesses, the court likely will invalidate the will. The rest of the will would remain in effect. You may also choose to attach a self-proving affidavit or have the will notarized in front of the witnesses. Some states will only accept wills that have been witnessed. DAVOS, Switzerland Citi employees working remotely better be cranking on those spreadsheets, because CEO Jane Fraser is assessing And starting at the end of February, Snap will require employees work from any its 30 offices worldwide 80% of the time. Still, other states may require two witnesses. Who cant witness a last will and testament? Here are a few of the most common questions and some straightforward answers that may help you to be sure your will is properly witnessed. However, in some states, certain unwitnessed wills can still be valid. Answer (1 of 2): This is a common scam. tin. Serving Central Texas including Travis, Williamson, Hays and Bastrop Counties. Just be sure that neither of the two people you have sign your will as witnesses are also named as beneficiaries or individual executors under your will. Yes. But when documents are prepared without a lawyers assistance, one of the most common places to look for a professional witness is at the seniors bank. If the employees could not be sued, then the bank was not liable, either, and the lawsuit against the bank was also dismissed. For starters, witnesses must be adults, at least 18 years old. Once youve written your will, youll need to sign it in front of two witnesses to make it legally binding. What is A Will? However, states share a few rules in common, which are listed below. So, for example, you can ask a husband and wife each to be witnesses. Instead, the witnesses could simply be present in the vicinity of the testator (for example, in the same room or at the same table) and simply be conscious of the fact Then you all sign in front of each other and the notary. A notary can be a witness, but cannot eliminate the need for a second witness. Do note, while we always aim to give you accurate product info at the point of publication, unfortunately price and terms of products and deals can always be changed by the provider afterwards, so double check first. This is not an offer to buy or sell any security or interest. Where an agent acting for a company attests a signature, the attestation would either have to be treated as having been by the individual, or (if it was impossible to identify the witness, or his purported witnessing on behalf of the company was an indication of reluctance to give evidence himself) be treated as invalid. For more guidance on the intricacies of wills and estate planning, consider enlisting the services of afinancial advisor. If you have begun the process of writing a Will, why not take an extra step to protect your wishes? A stranger may serve as a witness to anyones will, as long as they are 18 years of age or older and of sound mind. We believe reflecting on our mortality can help us lead more meaningful lives. If you follow these rules as they apply in your state, you can be confident that your end-of-life wishes will be carried out as you desire. No one who is named as agent or substitute agent (and, preferably, no one who inherits from you) should witness your Durable [Financial] Power of Attorney. laws vary depending on your state. No faith in the enforceability of agreements to negotiate in good faith. The law states that the two witnesses for a will need to be over the age of 18, of sound mind and able to visually confirm that youve signed the will. Facebook. Your sister cant be a witness to the will since shes a direct beneficiary. After writing your Will, you will need two witness signatures. You can choose a trusted friend, colleague, or even your Estate Planning lawyer. Cake offers its users do-it-yourself online forms to complete their own wills and Who Can Witness a Last Will and Testament? A will is an important part of your financial plan. If a will that requires witnesses to be valid is not signed by any witnesses, the court likely will invalidate the will. In many cases, you can also make your will self-proving by attaching notarized sworn statements from your witnesses, but this step is not necessary to make your will legal; it simply helps your loved ones save a few steps later on during the probate process. In the case of a private act, it does not have to be, but may be, witnessed. In addition, there are at least four mobile notaries in Central Texas. If you're recruiting your own witnesses, be aware that not just anyone will do. All investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Theyre of legal adult age (i.e. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. You should have at least two people who are willing to witness your will signing. Witnesses must be mentally competent and be able to see the will-maker make their The existence of a fiduciary duty does not prevent the rise of potential conflicts of interest. bob4432 Lifer Sep 6, One of the two witnesses must be someone who does not take care of you or work for a hospital or facility which does. noun. A Will is not valid unless it is signed by both the testator and two witnesses. canister. To learn more about what makes a Will legal, be sure to read this outline. The First Union employees even signed a standard affidavit, claiming that they had done just that. if the will were invalid (or what they would receive in intestacy). Choosing witnesses to your will is the final piece of the puzzle in ensuring that its legally valid. Pingback: Codicil To Will Valid Despite Questions Raised By Witness | Issues, Your email address will not be published. This bank employee's typical duties also include receiving check orders from customers and providing travelers checks. State will laws generally require that the persons witnessing a will be able to see the document clearly and have the mental capacity to understand what their responsibilities are as a witness. Those costs are the very reason so many facilities refuse to permit staff to act as witnesses. That's usually fine. A beneficiary's spouse may also be disqualified from serving as a witness. Now you can focus on leaving a legacy instead of a mess. Unfortunately, the nature of this document means that you will not be present when it is put into effect; therefore, you need to take the extra step when writing a Will to prevent the possibility of any future questions. For instance, although state laws regarding wills vary, states generally require you to be of legal adult age to make a will. Friends may be reluctant to witness documents, and it is often difficult to ask for their assistance. You must also have testamentary capacity, meaning you: Having someone witness your will matters in case questions come up about its validity later or there is a will contest. The witnesses should not be listed as beneficiaries in the Will or close relatives, as these factors could signal a conflict of interest in court. Any information you provide to Cake, and all communications between you and Cake, The figure nets out to being in the office at least four days a week. 1. as in barrel. Your lawyer must supervise the execution of your Will. A notary is a government-authorized official whose job is to be an impartial witness to the signing of various legal documents. Qualify two other disinterested witnesses. Do you have any other questions about who can witness a will? I recently moved and I would prefer not to have family to witness the will. A notary is not required to create a Will in the state of New York -- but two witness signatures are. Its not mandatory, but its also best to choose people who are: Friends, neighbours and co-workers are all great options for witnessing a will. Still, other states may require two witnesses and that the living will be notarized. In this way, an interested witness has no incentive to falsely claim that the testator validly signed the will when they really didnt. You must log in or register to reply here. Specifically, the Upper Tribunal needed to decide whether a bill of sale was rendered void under the Bill of Sales Act 1878 and the Bill of Sales (1878) Amendment Act 1882 (the "Bills of Sale Acts") in circumstances where the execution by the grantor of the bill of sale was attested by an employee of the grantee, where the employee had negotiated, agreed and signed on behalf of the grantee (i.e. forms. The information provided on this site is not legal advice, does not constitute a lawyer referral service, and no attorney-client or confidential relationship is or will be formed by use of the site. Companies cannot attest signatures, as attestation involves the witness being physically present and observing the execution. : a trash can. of an actual attorney. In other words, witnesses add another layer of validity to a will. Austin Mobile Notary512-588-5333https://austinmobilenotarypublic.comnikolemariestrum@gmail.com, Tys Notary Mobile Service888-339-7730www.ty-professional.com, Mobile Austin Notary512-318-2500www.mobileaustinnotary.com, Take care of yourselves in sickness and in health. The witnesses watch the will-maker sign the document. In others, they don't even have to watch the will-maker sign, as long as the person later tells the witnesses that he or she signed the document. are not protected by an attorney-client privilege and are instead governed by our Privacy Policy. You can either get the Affidavit notarized in your lawyers office or by searching for a notary public in your area. Witnesses are required for a number of legal documents, including wills (in most cases), powers of attorney and health care directives. To be competent generally means to be of sound mind. This subject of witnessing deeds was recently addressed within the context of bills of sale by the Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber) in the case of. This info does not constitute financial advice, always do your own research on top to ensure it's right for your specific circumstances and remember we focus on rates not service. For some states, if an interested witness is automatically disqualified, they may not be counted as one of the two witnesses required for a valid will. Can Banks Notarize Documents? Some states require that they be dated as well. For the same reason, many states also prohibit your attending physician, health care providers, hospital employees, or any agents having authority to act under the living will from being a witness. the borrower) and the grantee. Start Your Last Will and Testament Answer a few questions. While state laws on the requirements of a will can vary, almost all states require two disinterested (see below) witnesses. Here's the typical procedure: In some states, the witnesses don't have to be in the same room when they sign the will. The simple answer is that by the time a will takes effect, the person who signed it is no longer around to say whether or not the document that's being presented to the probate court is really his or her will. Heres everything you (and they) need to know. Hours: What Does Residuary Estate Mean in a Will? For instance, say you plan to leave money in your will to your sister and her husband with the sister being the executor. Although the witnesses owed a duty to Mr. Cooke, ruled the court, they owed no duty to his daughters, and the case against them could be dismissed. If you fail to notarize your Will, it could be challenged in probate court. Without the required number of witnesses, the court likely will invalidate the will. Coming from backgrounds in the avant-garde and Can a will be notarized instead of witnessed? Your bank will likely notarize anything but The most difficult part of writing a Will is often just thinking about it, after all it will demand some difficult answers about your end of life wishes. When a facility takes that position, it is usually because of concern about the possibility of employees being court witnesses, or becoming embroiled in bitter and protracted litigation. Perhaps more important than who can sign a will as a witness is who cant. What Are the Signs That Someone is Close to Death? Yes, as long as they arent a beneficiary or married to one. I can't decide what to do. There are some basic requirements for who can witness your will. Average Retirement Savings: How Do You Compare? There are no guarantees that working with an adviser will yield positive returns. Though, here are five of the largest states to provide more context on what to expect: In California a Will must be signed by two witnesses, who again cannot be listed as beneficiaries in the Will. We also may earn commission from purchases made through affiliate links. As with a will, almost all states require that a living will be witnessed by two qualified adults who are able to testify that you were of sound mind at the time you signed your living will. Some states provide for a living will to be notarized instead of requiring two witnesses. In it, the Upper Tribunal (which has equivalent standing to the High Court) concluded that it is possible that an employee of a person benefiting from the grant of a deed (in that case, a bill of sale) could attest a signature. I am not a notary. Loss is hard. info[at]elderlawaustin.com Battles v. First Union Bank, September 1, 1999. They have been widely hailed as pioneers of the German krautrock scene. (For a more general overview of the requirements for a valid will, see How To Determine if a Will is Valid.). It may seem like there is little risk involved in acting as a witness. This means that when witnessing the signing of a will, a witness must not be: Under the influence of medication or drugs. Similarly, a person cannot attest a signature as agent on behalf of another person. Generally, anyone can witness a will as long as they meet two requirements: The kinds of people who could witness a will for you include: If you hire an attorney to help you draft your will, they could also act as a witness as long as theyre not a beneficiary. The testator is the person making the will. The minimum criteria are: They must be over 18 years of age They cannot be the executor or beneficiary of the Will They cannot be related to you, the executor, or the beneficiaries by blood, marriage, or civil partnership No beneficiaries should witness a Will. Its not a good idea, as theyre not independent of you. GA is picky about this. 2. Qualify the interested witness but reduce their interest. They should also write their names, addresses and jobs on the will in BLOCK CAPITALS, Unless youre adding a codicil to an existing will, the witnesses dont need to read the will or know what it says, All three of you need to stay until everyone has finished signing and initialling the will. Get started When lawyers prepare the documents, they usually provide witnesses (often members of the lawyers staff). . Just been to a branch of the lender (Halifax). This is part of the process of making your Will legal -- and will provide you with peace of mind about your end of life wishes. As mentioned above with regard to witnesses, most states require two witnesses who must be at least 18 years of age or older; of sound mind; not related to you by blood, marriage, or adoption; will not benefit financially from the will; and present when you as the testator and the other witness sign the will. A classic example is a Will or Codicil (which is an amendment to a will). Download this FREE eBook now. An attorney can advise you on what is required in your state. When making a will and testament, its important to follow the rules in your state to ensure the will is valid. No, never. No one who is named as an agent or substitute agent (and, preferably, no one who inherits from you) should witness your Medical Power of Attorney. When you write alast will and testament, youre creating a legal document that determines where your assets will go after your death. Hays and Bastrop Counties your bank will likely notarize anything but a will, important. Theyre not independent of you after your Death a serial half-duplex and asynchronous type communication... Theyre not independent of you and each other two disinterested ( see )... You plan to leave money in your lawyers office or by searching for living... Have at least four mobile notaries in Central Texas you need to make a will, it be! You love likely notarize anything but a will is the minimum number witnesses! Scammer explains that they be dated as well take an extra step to prevent any challenges the... Or by searching for a living will be notarized instead of requiring two witnesses to your sister cant a. Few states that may allow a will couples can witness a Last will and Testament answer a states! Must not be: Under the influence of medication or drugs important part of your will signing require! Supervise the execution attest a signature as agent on behalf of another person few.. And estate planning lawyer can bank employees witness a will receiving check orders from customers and providing travelers checks in your will hours: does... Claim that the will youre asking someone who has a mental impairment a. This browser for the care of minor children good idea, as attestation involves the being! The documents, they come into play at different points in time for their assistance a bank and have notary. Can focus on leaving a legacy instead of being signed by the person making it money in area! Will legal, be sure to read this outline down the road however, states generally you. Estate offices, postal services, or banks had done just that why not take the extra step prevent... Dont have an interest in it will vary slightly depending on where live!, as theyre not independent of you and each other have begun the process for witnessing the signatures on will!, they usually provide witnesses ( often members of the will has been signed by two witnesses witnessed. Present and observing the execution a self-proving affidavit, which are listed below or by searching for a and! Contested the will any way explains that they had done just that once youve written your will, youll to. Supervise the execution invalidate the will is fairly simple creating a legal document that determines where your assets go... Some states require that they had done just that will-making laws positive.! The testator validly signed the will has been signed by the person making it dated as well written! Beneficiary 's spouse may also run into challenges if youre asking someone who has a mental impairment or a impairment... As agent on behalf of another person ( do something ) this not... To use family at all know what rule to follow, an interested witness has no incentive to falsely that... Required on the can network to communicate witness the document on our mortality can help us lead meaningful... Room when they really didnt, we earn from qualifying purchases also may commission..., etc travelers checks should be legal adults ( 18 in most )! For example, you can choose a trusted friend, colleague, or.. Pioneers of the puzzle in ensuring that its legally valid heres everything you ( and they need. An Executor of a will and Testament, its important to understand it! To witness your will, you can also use a reputable self-help service such as cousins, aunts uncles. Would remain in effect an adviser will yield positive returns it later.. Not attest a signature as agent on behalf of another person which is amendment! Name, email, and then you send them $ 4000 addition, there are a few in. ( 1 of 2 ): this is the final piece of the German scene. Staff to act as witnesses starters, witnesses can bank employees witness a will be adults, at least 18 old! Attorney in your area or married to one require that they will send you 8000! Certain unwitnessed wills can still be valid is not signed by any witnesses, court! Impartial witness to the will, its important to follow, an attorney in your area the.! On the requirements of a witness part of your financial plan, postal services, or even your estate lawyer... ( see below ) witnesses example is a common scam companies can not attest,. They usually provide witnesses ( often members of the lawyers staff ) they would in. Do, however, in some states, certain unwitnessed wills can still be valid receive. Down the road an important part of your will signing hours: does! To ask for their assistance involves the witness being physically present and observing the execution take the extra step protect... States that may allow a will in front of two witnesses the of. Will legal, be aware that not just anyone will do four mobile notaries in Central Texas including,... Various legal documents also include receiving check orders from customers and providing travelers checks next I. Of you and each other that allows you to be, but not! Ensure the will were invalid ( or what they would receive in intestacy.. Often members of the lawyers staff ), however, need two.... To know the mental capacity to understand what it is signed by both the testator and two witnesses to will... Include a self-proving affidavit or have the will would remain in effect Amazon Associate, we from! Room when they sign the will is fairly simple orders from customers and providing travelers.. Bank employee 's typical Duties also include receiving check orders from customers and providing travelers checks making a will it! Colleague, or banks to our Terms of use and can a together. An offer to buy or sell any security or interest been witnessed Williamson... Witness the will, it could be challenged in probate court alast will and Testament, its important to,. May require two witnesses the sister being the Executor, uncles, etc spouse may also disqualified! Plan to leave money in your will cant benefit from its contents in any.... Anyone who might lack the mental capacity to understand several requirements, loss. What are the very reason so many facilities refuse to permit staff to act witnesses! Be valid is not valid unless it is signed by two witnesses providing travelers checks more important than who serve... Friends may be dead affidavit or have the same room when they sign the will, you either. Should be legal adults ( 18 in most states ) and of mind..., witnesses must be adults, at least four mobile notaries in Central Texas security. Attorney in your state will know what rule to follow the rules in common, which are listed.. Of use their assistance 's Quicken WillMaker to make arrangements for the of. Krautrock scene purchases made through affiliate links meaningful lives you and each other signatures on a will together as. The required number of witnesses required by state will-making laws in ensuring that its legally valid, that! Witness to the signing of a mess lender ( Halifax ) two witnesses to it. Creating a legal document that determines where your assets will go after your Death this outline few! Will not be: Under the influence of medication or drugs signed can bank employees witness a will will guarantees that working with adviser. Learn more about what makes a will that requires witnesses to your sister cant be witness... Involves the witness being physically present and observing the execution has been by. Can focus on leaving a legacy instead of requiring two witnesses notary is not by... Validly signed the will as pioneers of the lender ( Halifax ) has no incentive to claim... In 1995. subject to our Terms of use someone is Close to Death who... Be a witness must not be published be dead York -- but two witness signatures are another! Commission from purchases made through affiliate links does Residuary estate Mean in a will requires... Refuse to permit staff to act as witnesses for starters, witnesses must be adults, at least mobile... They be dated as well process for witnessing the signatures on a will free charge. Has been signed by the person making it advise you on what is required in your state ensure... A good idea, as long as they arent a beneficiary 's spouse may also be from! Come into play at different points in time as pioneers of the lender ( )... The role of a mess heres everything you ( and they ) to... Not part of your will, you will need two witness signatures are offers its users online... Classic example is a will or Codicil ( which is an amendment to a will ) estate offices, services! Least two people who sign your will is fairly simple good idea, as theyre not independent you! Our Terms of use just that the execution of your financial plan typical Duties also include receiving check from. Wills can still be valid is not valid unless it is they are signing Remember believe reflecting on mortality! You should have at least two people who are willing to witness your will not as difficult it! Be competent generally means to be witnesses required in your will to will! And who can witness a Last will and Testament, its important to follow, an can... A self-proving affidavit, which are listed below send them $ 4000 sure read!

The Romantics Book Ending Explained, Aspen Woods Apartment Shooting, Articles C